miami’s best

key lime pie

Shop Pies
See Our Allergy Info
Person holding a homemade key lime pie with a graham cracker crust in a glass pie dish

freshly baked favorites

6-Inch Personal Pan Pie 6-Inch Personal Pan Pie 6-Inch Personal Pan Pie
Quick View
6-Inch Personal Pan Pie
from $20.00

6” personal key lime pie. Serves One.

Perfect for gifting or treating your whole table.

Minimum Order of 3 when purchased alone. No minimum when added to an order with a 10” pie.

Choose Gift Box with Bow & Card for a ready-to-gift pie that includes a heartfelt “Grateful for You” card - no extra wrapping needed.

Gluten free option available. Please inquire at info@misspieami.com.

10-Inch Key Lime Pie 10-Inch Key Lime Pie 10-Inch Key Lime Pie
Quick View
10-Inch Key Lime Pie
from $60.00

The OG. Serves 8

As originally served at the legendary Blue Collar and Mignonette Restaurants.

Will keep in refrigerator for 1 week, or in freezer for up to 2 months.

Choose Gift Box with Bow & Card for a ready-to-gift pie that includes a heartfelt “Grateful for You” card - no extra wrapping needed.

4.5-Inch Mini Pie 4.5-Inch Mini Pie 4.5-Inch Mini Pie
4.5-Inch Mini Pie
from $12.00

Our petite 4.5” key lime pie.

The event standard.

Minimum order of 5 when purchased alone. No minimum when added to an order with a 10” pie.

Choose Gift Box with Bow & Card for a ready-to-gift pie that includes a heartfelt “Grateful for You” card - no extra wrapping needed.

Gluten free option available. Please inquire at info@misspieami.com.

pies that make life sweeter

Close-up of a slice of key lime pie with a graham cracker crust and whipped cream topping

  • Nothing says Holiday in Miami like Key Lime Pie.

    (And Every Day’s a Holiday.)

    #dale

  • Serve straight from the fridge & top your slice with a generous dollop of whipped cream.

    As presented at The Cafe at Books & Books and the legendary Blue Collar and Mignonette restaurants.

  • Full-sized, Personal Pan or Mini Key Lime Pies

    Contact us for details.

  • Florida shipping now available!

    For orders outside of Florida, please email us at Info@MissPieAmi.com for a quote.

a florida tradition

Key Lime Pie Perfected Over Decades, A Slice of Sunshine, From Our Family to Yours

Learn More
Smiling woman holding a pie plate while knocking on the door of a yellow wooden building
Key lime citrus tree with green limes, glossy leaves, and small blossoms covered in raindrops

The Key Lime (Citrus x aurantifolia)

word on the street

Article cover titled “The Best Key Lime Pie in Miami,” featuring a slice of key lime pie topped with whipped cream and crumbs.
Slice of key lime pie topped with whipped cream on a plate
Meghan Perkins holds a key lime pie in front of a banana-patterned backdrop, alongside an article about her pies at Blue Collar and Mignonette in Miami.
Slice of Miami key lime pie with whipped cream on a graham cracker crust
Slice of Miami key lime pie with whipped cream on a graham cracker crust
Travel + Leisure webpage titled “Top 5 Spots for Key Lime Pie in Miami,” featuring a key lime pie photo and a Blue Collar restaurant listing.

Questions?

Let’s figure it out together—drop us a note and we’ll reply soon.